Clutch alternatives

01Why people leave Clutch

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

1. Wallet-pass loyalty

   WWalletlyWalletly

   Walletly is the closest fit if your switch is about loyalty campaigns across online and in-store redemptions. The listing says it supports wallet-based loyalty passes and agency sub-accounts with white-label scanning. Its listed starting price is $15, giving you a public point of comparison where Clutch’s pricing is opaque.

   Trade-off: Compare plan details before committing annually; the listing flags that as a consideration.

   Walletly review
   6.2/10

   from
   $15/mo
2. Retail loyalty

   Kangaroo RewardsKangaroo Rewards

   Kangaroo Rewards fits businesses moving from Clutch for a loyalty program with campaign coverage, especially single-store or multi-location retailers. It also lists a branded rewards app. The starting price is $79, so it is easier to budget against than a vendor with no published starting price, though that alone does not settle total cost.

   Trade-off: Check integration caps and monthly cost before switching.

   Kangaroo Rewards review
   5.9/10

   from
   $79/mo
3. Restaurant marketing

   ThanxThanx

   Thanx is a fit if Clutch’s loyalty and campaign features are being replaced by a restaurant-focused suite. Its listed strengths include multi-location restaurant brands, loyalty with ordering, and automated guest campaigns. That is a more specific match for restaurant teams than a general loyalty shortlist, but the price is not published.

   Trade-off: Custom pricing leaves costs unclear.

   Thanx review
   6.5/10

   from
   Custom
4. Food and beverage

   ComoComo

   Como is worth comparing if your Clutch use centers on food and beverage loyalty, a branded app, or combining ordering and marketing. Those are its stated best-fit areas. It may suit a narrower vertical need better than choosing on broad feature coverage alone, but the available information does not provide a public starting price.

   Trade-off: Custom-quote pricing and limited public evidence make comparison harder.

   Como review
   6.0/10

   from
   Custom
5. Square POS users

   Square LoyaltySquare Loyalty

   Square Loyalty makes the shortlist if you already use Square POS and want to pair loyalty with marketing. Its listed starting price is $60 per location, which gives operators a concrete figure to compare with Clutch’s opaque pricing. The fit is specifically tied to Square users and locations within the listed visit tier.

   Trade-off: $60 per location monthly; reward mechanics are unclear.

   Square Loyalty review
   5.0/10

   from
   $60/mo
6. Local repeat visits

   FivestarsFivestars

   Fivestars targets local businesses focused on repeat visits and automated customer follow-ups. That makes it a possible alternative when the main job is customer retention rather than a broader marketing stack. Its price is not published on the vendor's site, so request full terms before treating it as a lower-cost replacement.

   Trade-off: Pricing and contract terms need checking.

   Fivestars review
   5.8/10

   from
   Custom
7. Restaurant engagement

   PunchhPunchh

   Punchh is aimed at restaurant brands consolidating guest tools, with personalized loyalty offers and branded digital ordering among its listed strengths. Consider it if those needs are more important than Clutch’s broader loyalty-and-campaign positioning. The pricing page gives no public price, so ask for a quote and scope before comparing vendors.

   Trade-off: No public price; the listing also flags user-reported red flags.

   Punchh review
   5.8/10

   from
   Custom

03Side by side

Tool	Score	From	Free plan	Best for
Clutch Clutch (current)	5.8	Custom	No	Teams consolidating loyalty and campaigns
WWalletly Walletly	6.2	$15/mo	No	Businesses using wallet-based loyalty passes
Kangaroo Rewards Kangaroo Rewards	5.9	$79/mo	No	Single-store businesses starting loyalty
Thanx Thanx	6.5	Custom	No	Multi-location restaurant brands
Como Como	6.0	Custom	No	Food and beverage loyalty programs
Square Loyalty Square Loyalty	5.0	$60/mo	No	Businesses already using Square POS
Fivestars Fivestars	5.8	Custom	No	Local businesses focused on repeat visits
Punchh Punchh	5.8	Custom	No	Restaurant brands consolidating guest tools

Prices from each vendor's pricing page, checked Nov 6, 2026.