We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose OnTheClock if you need a time clock, scheduling and PTO with public per-employee pricing: its time-tracking plan is $4 per employee monthly plus a $5 monthly base fee, and payroll adds $6 per paid employee plus $40 monthly. Choose Paycom if you want broader HR and payroll in one database, employee self-service and dedicated support. Paycom does not publish rates, so compare it only after getting a quote; neither product lists a free plan.
01Side by side
| OnTheClock | Paycom | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $4/employee monthly, plus $5 monthly base fee | Not published; customized quote |
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Best for | Small businesses needing time and PTO tracking | Organizations seeking customized HR software |
| Core strength | Time tracking, scheduling and PTO management | Automated HR and payroll in one database |
| Learning curve | Ease-of-use score: 7/10; details not published | Ease-of-use score: 7/10; details not published |
| Integrations/data | Payroll integrations; integration breadth not published | Single database; changes flow across software |
| Team/seat costs | $4 per employee; payroll adds $6 per paid employee | Custom pricing; seat rates not published |
| Support | Review score: 5/10 | Dedicated team; review score: 6/10 |
OnTheClock Choose OnTheClock if
- Choose OnTheClock if you need time clocks, scheduling and PTO.
- Choose OnTheClock if per-employee pricing helps you budget.
- Choose OnTheClock if you want payroll with published add-on pricing.
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want HR and payroll in one database.
- Choose Paycom if employees should manage their own HR information.
- Choose Paycom if dedicated implementation and ongoing support matter.
02Pricing compared
OnTheClock publishes per-employee prices. Its time-tracking, scheduling and PTO plan is $4 per employee per month, plus a $5 monthly base fee. Payroll adds $6 per paid employee per month and a $40 monthly base fee. The pricing details list a 30-day free trial, no free plan and no annual rate.
Paycom does not publish monthly or annual rates, and its pricing page lists no free trial or free plan. Pricing is customized by workforce size and selected modules, so you’ll need a quote to compare its total cost with OnTheClock. Paycom’s payroll and other modules have no published prices. OnTheClock also lists a one-time $250 fee for Payroll Professional migration or onboarding.
03Features and depth
OnTheClock is focused on time and attendance workflows: employees can clock in on phones, desktops, tablets or kiosks, with GPS, geofencing and biometric options for verification. Managers can create schedules, handle PTO requests and review and approve timecards. Approved hours flow into payroll, which includes tax filing, direct deposit, W-2s and 1099s.
Paycom covers a wider HR and payroll scope in one database. Its listed tools include Beti for payroll preparation and employee error correction, GONE for automated time-off decisions, and IWant AI for questions about employee profiles, applicant data, policies and dashboards. Employees can also manage their own HR and payroll information. Paycom lists Talent Acquisition, Time and Labor Management, Talent Management and HR Management as modules, but module pricing and the exact core setup are not published. OnTheClock is the more directly specified fit for time tracking and scheduling; Paycom’s feature set extends further into HR.
04Ease of use and learning curve
Our review scores give both products 7/10 for ease of use, so that measure alone does not separate them. OnTheClock’s listed scope is narrower: time tracking, scheduling, PTO and payroll. Paycom brings those payroll workflows into a broader HR system, including employee self-service and automated tools; the exact setup depends on the modules selected.
Paycom says clients receive a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing and ongoing support. OnTheClock lists payroll migration or onboarding as a one-time $250 option for Payroll Professional. Neither product’s published details specify setup time or training requirements, so ask each vendor what implementation includes before comparing the effort involved.
Questions people ask
Who is Paycom's biggest competitor?
The published information does not identify Paycom’s biggest competitor, and that can depend on whether you mean payroll, HR software or a particular company size. Paycom’s listed alternatives are not named. Compare vendors against your required modules and get quotes before treating any one provider as its closest rival.
What is the Paycom controversy?
The published information does not substantiate a specific Paycom controversy. It covers product features, custom pricing and support, but not allegations or disputes. We would not treat an unspecified controversy as fact; check reliable reporting and Paycom’s response for the particular claim you have in mind.
Which is better, Paycom or ADP?
The published information does not include ADP’s features, pricing or terms, so we can’t make a grounded Paycom-versus-ADP verdict. Paycom’s rates are custom and unpublished here. Compare written quotes and the modules each provider includes, especially payroll, time tracking and HR support.
Is Paycom a good payroll system?
Paycom lists automated payroll through Beti, which lets employees find and fix errors before payroll runs, plus employee self-service and dedicated support. That may suit organizations seeking payroll within a broader HR system. Its pricing is not published, though, so get a quote to judge value against your needs.