We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Workday covers connected HR and finance workflows, so a replacement may not be a like-for-like swap. The complaints in Reddit threads focus on applicant friction, confusing forms and a rigid-feeling experience; one thread also includes disputed claims about age-based rejections. Our shortlist spans broad HR platforms and narrower tools for benefits, global hiring or hourly scheduling. Compare scope before comparing prices: several alternatives have quote-only or unclear total costs, and some replace only part of Workday’s footprint.
01Why people leave Workday
Applicants find the process frustrating
Reddit users describe repeated account creation, awkward application forms and resume-parsing problems. Those are user reports, not a measure of every employer’s setup.
Forms and workflows feel rigid
One Reddit thread complains about confusing fields, broken copy-and-paste and frequent notifications; another commenter describes Workday as monolithic and inflexible.
Rejection decisions feel opaque
A Reddit poster suspects Workday rejects applicants based on age, while commenters dispute that claim. The thread reflects uncertainty, not proof of automated age-based rejection.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Modular workforce platform
RipplingRipplingRippling is the closest fit here if you want a broad workforce platform rather than a narrow scheduling or benefits tool. Its listed use cases include consolidating HR and payroll, modular workforce tools and global employees. The starting price is $8, but the pricing page warns that total pricing is unclear, so request a full quote before comparing it with Workday.
Trade-off: Total costs are unclear; confirm which modules your replacement needs.
6.2/10from
$8/mo - Core HR and hiring
BambooHRBambooHRBambooHR fits teams focused on core HR records, hiring and onboarding, rather than reproducing every connected HR-and-finance workflow Workday may handle. The pricing page starts at $10.25 and notes published base rates, which helps with an initial comparison. Budget separately for add-ons: their prices are not published on the vendor's site.
Trade-off: Unpriced add-ons make the base rate an incomplete budget.
6.7/10from
$10.25/mo - Complex workforce operations
UKG ProUKG ProUKG Pro is worth comparing if your Workday setup supports broad HR and payroll needs alongside complex workforce schedules or union scheduling. Those are its listed strengths, making it a more relevant option for organizations with scheduling complexity than a basic shift app. Pricing is not published; the pricing page says to get a quote and check the employee experience.
Trade-off: Quote-only pricing; check employee experience before committing.
5.8/10from
Custom - Broad HCM coverage
DayforceDayforceDayforce is listed for organizations seeking broad HCM coverage and teams evaluating global payroll, so it may suit buyers who need more than applicant tracking or shift scheduling. The pricing page gives no public starting price and flags user complaints about usability and reporting. Treat those complaints as a reason to scrutinize the fit, not as a guarantee of your experience.
Trade-off: Quote-only pricing and reported usability and reporting complaints.
4.4/10from
Custom - Global hiring and payroll
DeelDeelDeel is a more targeted choice if your Workday use includes hiring across borders, managing contractors in multiple countries or combining payroll and HR. The pricing page starts at $14, but EOR is listed at $599 per employee monthly, so check which service and pricing apply to your workforce. Support feedback is mixed, according to the listing.
Trade-off: EOR costs $599 per employee monthly; support feedback is mixed.
6.3/10from
$14/mo - Hourly team operations
ConnecteamConnecteamConnecteam may work if the part of Workday you need to replace is hourly-team scheduling and time tracking, especially when you are trying to reduce the number of workforce tools. The pricing page includes a free plan and a $29 starting price. It is a narrower fit than a broad HR-and-finance platform; check hub costs and reporting needs.
Trade-off: A narrower fit; check hub costs and reporting coverage.
6.8/10from
$29/mofree plan - Benefits administration
PlanSourcePlanSourcePlanSource is a focused option if benefits administration is the Workday workflow you want to change. Its listed strengths are employee benefits management, enrollment guidance and implementation support for resellers. It is not presented as a full HR-and-finance replacement, and pricing is not published on the vendor's site, which makes a direct cost comparison difficult.
Trade-off: Focused on benefits; pricing is not published.
5.5/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Workday Workday (current) | 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams managing HR and finance together |
| Rippling Rippling | 6.2 | $8/mo | No | Teams consolidating HR and payroll |
| BambooHR BambooHR | 6.7 | $10.25/mo | No | Teams consolidating core HR records |
| UKG Pro UKG Pro | 5.8 | Custom | No | Organizations consolidating HR and payroll |
| Dayforce Dayforce | 4.4 | Custom | No | Organizations seeking broad HCM coverage |
| Deel Deel | 6.3 | $14/mo | No | Companies hiring employees across borders |
| Connecteam Connecteam | 6.8 | $29/mo | Yes | Small teams needing a free starting plan |
| PlanSource PlanSource | 5.5 | Custom | No | HR teams managing employee benefits |
Questions people ask
Is Workday a competitor of ServiceNow?
The published material does not establish whether Workday and ServiceNow compete directly. It describes Workday in terms of connected HR and finance workflows, while providing no detail about ServiceNow’s products or overlap. Compare the specific workflows and products under consideration rather than assuming the platforms are interchangeable.
What are the top 5 workforce management software options?
From the alternatives covered here—not a market-wide ranking—compare Rippling, UKG Pro, Dayforce, Connecteam and When I Work. Their listed fits range from broad workforce tools to scheduling and hourly-team operations. Check scope and pricing: the published information lists quote-only pricing for UKG Pro and Dayforce and add-on costs for When I Work.
Is Workday an ERP or CRM?
The published material frames Workday as a platform connecting HR and finance, and a Reddit commenter describes it as an HRIS. That points more toward HR and business-management software than a CRM, but the material does not provide a formal product-category definition. Check which Workday products your organization actually uses before choosing a replacement.