We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Square covers POS and online sales, and a free plan is listed. But the published pricing information does not give a starting price, and the full payment costs need checking before you switch. Reddit threads include reports of accounts being closed and funds held; commenters also point to possible risk flags and say many businesses use Square without problems. These options suit different needs, from POS to online payments, so compare the fit and listed costs rather than treating them as direct replacements.
01Why people leave Square
Unexpected account closures
Reddit users report accounts closed with little notice and funds held. Other commenters suggest risk flags may explain some cases, so these reports are not proof of a general pattern.
Payment costs need checking
Square’s full payment costs are a stated concern, but the published material gives no rates. Compare the fees for your sales before choosing a replacement.
Support concerns during disruptions
One Reddit poster said phone support was unavailable until Monday after a Saturday closure. That is an individual report, not a published support guarantee.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- POS and operations
CloverCloverClover is the closest fit here if you want POS and operations tools rather than a payments-only alternative. Its listing also names restaurant-specific plans and free software for small businesses. The pricing page summary gives a starting price of $29.95 and says a free plan is available, so check which plan and hardware fit before moving.
Trade-off: Price hardware and processing costs before switching.
6.5/10from
$29.95/mofree plan - Online payments
PayPalPayPalPayPal is worth comparing if your priority is accepting online payments and offering shoppers multiple payment options, rather than replacing every part of Square’s POS setup. Its listing also points to digital-wallet use. The published price is from $5, with a free plan listed; business fees and dispute concerns are reasons to review the terms first.
Trade-off: Business fees and dispute concerns temper the appeal.
6.3/10from
$5/mofree plan - Gateway and merchant account
Authorize.NetAuthorize.NetAuthorize.Net may fit businesses looking for a merchant account and payment gateway, especially if recurring payments or taking payments across several channels matter. Those are explicit strengths in its listing. The listed starting price is $25, before transaction costs, so compare the combined cost with Square rather than treating the monthly fee as the full bill.
Trade-off: Budget for the monthly fee and transaction costs.
6.5/10from
$25/mo - Cross-channel payments
WindcaveWindcaveWindcave is a candidate if you need payments across channels or global acquiring. Its listing describes a broad payment platform, but gives no starting price, so it is hard to compare on cost from the published information. Ask for pricing tied to your markets and payment needs before deciding whether it can replace your current setup.
Trade-off: Pricing is opaque, with some localized user concerns.
6.0/10from
Custom - Group payments
Cheddar UpCheddar UpCheddar Up is a more targeted option for groups collecting dues or running fundraisers that need forms, waivers or multiple managers. It is not presented as a general POS replacement, so it fits best when those group-payment tasks are the part of Square you need to replace. Its listed price starts at $15, with a free plan available.
Trade-off: Card fees can take a noticeable cut.
6.5/10from
$15/mofree plan - Church giving
VancoVancoVanco is a focused alternative for churches starting online giving or organizations that need event-management tools. Its listing also describes processing tiers, making it more relevant to those use cases than to a general retail POS switch. The listed starting price is $54, and a free plan is available; check transaction fees and optional add-ons as well.
Trade-off: The free plan still has transaction fees; add-ons are optional.
6.1/10from
$54/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Square Square (current) | 6.9 | Free | Yes | Small sellers needing POS and online sales |
| Clover Clover | 6.5 | $29.95/mo | Yes | Merchants wanting POS and operations tools |
| PayPal PayPal | 6.3 | $5/mo | Yes | Shoppers wanting a digital wallet |
| Authorize.Net Authorize.Net | 6.5 | $25/mo | No | Businesses needing a merchant account and gateway |
| Windcave Windcave | 6.0 | Custom | No | Businesses taking payments across channels |
| Cheddar Up Cheddar Up | 6.5 | $15/mo | Yes | Groups collecting dues and payments |
| Vanco Vanco | 6.1 | $54/mo | Yes | Churches starting online giving |
Questions people ask
Are there cheaper alternatives to Square?
The pricing page show free plans for Square, PayPal, Clover, Cheddar Up and Vanco, but they do not provide enough detail to compare total payment costs. Listed starting prices include $5 for PayPal, $15 for Cheddar Up and $29.95 for Clover. Compare transaction fees and plan limits before calling any option cheaper.
What is the downside of using Square?
The published summary flags full payment costs and account risk as trade-offs. Reddit users report closures and held funds, while commenters also suggest some closures may involve risk flags and note that many businesses use Square without problems. Treat those posts as individual reports, not proof that every account faces the same risk.
Is Square or Wix better?
The published information does not include Wix pricing or features, so we cannot make a grounded comparison. Square is described here as covering POS and online sales, with a free plan listed. Compare Wix’s current pricing, payment fees and the sales tools you need against those Square terms before choosing.
Is Square still free?
The pricing page says Square has a free plan, but gives no starting price and does not specify which features or limits apply. It also flags full payment costs as something to check. Confirm current plan details and transaction fees with Square before assuming your sales will have no costs.