We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
RSA SecurID starts at $3 in our listing, but unclear limits and extra costs can make the real bill harder to judge. Reddit users also describe wanting a lower-cost personal token or working around rules that prohibit phones and USB devices. The options here range from workforce SSO to identity governance; they are not all direct token replacements. We don’t have sourced confirmation of hardware-token support for these alternatives, so verify that requirement before planning a migration.
01Why people leave RSA SecurID
The price feels steep for personal use
In one Reddit thread, a user wanted a keychain two-factor device for personal accounts but said RSA SecurID’s cost did not work for that use.
Device rules limit authentication choices
A Reddit user described a workplace that forbids phones and USB devices, making the choice of a portable second factor a practical constraint.
Teams want a different admin experience
In a sysadmin thread, one commenter reported switching from RSA to Duo and finding administration easy so far; that is one user’s account, not a general finding.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Small workforce teams
OneLoginOneLoginOneLogin is a practical shortlist candidate if you want workforce SSO, user provisioning across apps and support for hybrid identity environments. Its listed starting price is $3, matching RSA SecurID’s listed starting point rather than promising an automatic saving. Compare the Basic plan’s cap and the unpublished costs before moving users or budgeting for a wider rollout.
Trade-off: Basic is capped, and several costs are not published.
7.0/10from
$3/mo - Broad identity integrations
OktaOktaConsider Okta if your replacement needs to cover workforce and customer access, with broad identity integrations and existing Okta workflows in the mix. The listed starting price is $6, above RSA SecurID’s $3 entry point, so this is a fit-led choice rather than a lower-price pick. Check higher-tier costs and the migration work before committing.
Trade-off: Higher-tier costs and migration effort need checking.
7.0/10from
$6/mo - App identity and SSO
Auth0Auth0Auth0 fits teams that need enterprise SSO and SCIM for applications, or need to manage user and machine identity with granular access controls. Its listing says from $35 and notes a free plan. Before switching, check the monthly active user caps and total cost; the headline entry price alone won’t tell you whether your usage fits.
Trade-off: Monthly active user caps and total cost need scrutiny.
6.3/10from
$35/mofree plan - Access governance
LumosLumosLumos is worth considering if the project is broader than replacing an authentication tool: its listed fit includes employee and machine access, AI agent access, and automated access reviews. That makes it relevant when you are consolidating identity controls. Pricing is not published on the vendor's site, so you may need a sales conversation to size the cost.
Trade-off: Opaque pricing makes it hard to budget upfront.
6.5/10from
Custom - Time-limited privileged access
OpalOpalOpal’s listed strengths include governing access across identity types, time-limited privileged access, and formal approval and review workflows. That may fit an organization trying to tighten access governance as it leaves RSA SecurID, rather than seeking only a token swap. The listing shows a $39 starting price and a free plan; confirm seat minimums and full pricing.
Trade-off: Seat minimums and complete public pricing are unclear.
6.0/10from
$39/mofree plan - Enterprise governance
SailPointSailPointSailPoint suits enterprises that need broad governance across many identity types and are prepared for a custom implementation. It is a possible direction if leaving RSA SecurID is part of a wider identity-governance project, not a like-for-like MFA change. Pricing is not published on the vendor's site, and reports describe workflows as complex and clunky.
Trade-off: Pricing is opaque, and workflows may feel complex.
6.2/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 RSA SecurID RSA SecurID (current) | 6.5 | $3/mo | No | Regulated organizations with mixed environments |
| OneLogin OneLogin | 7.0 | $3/mo | No | Small teams needing workforce SSO |
| Okta Okta | 7.0 | $6/mo | No | Teams needing broad identity integrations |
| Auth0 Auth0 | 6.3 | $35/mo | Yes | Teams needing enterprise SSO and SCIM |
| Lumos Lumos | 6.5 | Custom | No | Teams governing employee and machine access |
| Opal Opal | 6.0 | $39/mo | Yes | Teams governing access across many identity types |
| SailPoint SailPoint | 6.2 | Custom | No | Enterprises governing many identity types |
Questions people ask
Which RSA SecurID alternative has the lowest listed starting price?
RSA SecurID and OneLogin are both listed from $3. That does not establish which will cost less for your organization: OneLogin’s Basic plan is capped, and several costs are unpublished. Compare the plan limits and full quote against your user count and required features.
Do these alternatives support hardware tokens?
The published summaries do not confirm hardware-token support for Okta, OneLogin, Auth0, Lumos, Opal or SailPoint. If key fobs or other hardware tokens are mandatory, ask each vendor to confirm supported devices, enrollment and recovery options before you plan a switch.
Are these direct replacements for RSA SecurID?
Not necessarily. The options listed cover different needs, including workforce SSO, app identity and access governance. The published information does not establish that each replaces RSA SecurID’s token workflows. First document your authentication, device and administration requirements, then confirm product fit with the vendor.