We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Pirate Ship.
Choose Pirate Ship for a no-monthly-fee way to compare USPS and UPS rates and print labels; you still pay for postage and labels. Choose ShipperHQ if your store needs configurable checkout rates, delivery dates, dimensional packing, freight, or duties and taxes. ShipperHQ offers a 15-day trial, but its prices are not published and vary by ecommerce platform. The better fit depends on whether you need straightforward label buying or deeper control over ecommerce shipping.
01Side by side
| Pirate Ship | ShipperHQ | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $0/month; pay for postage and labels | Not published; contact ShipperHQ |
| Free plan | Free Account; no monthly fees or minimums | No free plan; 15-day trial |
| Best for | Shippers comparing USPS and UPS rates | Stores managing complex checkout shipping |
| Core strength | Rate comparison and label printing | Shipping rules, delivery dates, freight, duties |
| Learning curve | Review ease-of-use score: 8/10 | Review ease-of-use score: 5.5/10 |
| Integrations/data | Store integrations not specified | Pricing varies by ecommerce platform |
| Team/seat costs | No monthly fees; per-seat costs not published | Per-seat costs not published |
| Support | Review support score: 6/10 | Review support score: 6.5/10 |
Pirate Ship Choose Pirate Ship if
- Choose Pirate Ship if you want no monthly software fee.
- Choose Pirate Ship if USPS and UPS rate comparison is enough.
- Choose Pirate Ship if you need bulk label printing and saved presets.
ShipperHQ Choose ShipperHQ if
- Choose ShipperHQ if checkout shipping rules matter to your store.
- Choose ShipperHQ if you need delivery dates or dimensional packing.
- Choose ShipperHQ if freight or duties and taxes belong at checkout.
02Pricing compared
Pirate Ship has the clearer price: its Free Account has no monthly fee, no volume minimums, and no commitment. You still pay for postage and shipping labels; “free” means the software account, not shipping. The pricing page does not publish annual billing.
ShipperHQ offers a 15-day trial, but monthly and annual prices are not published and vary by ecommerce platform. Its listed tiers set limits instead: Essential lists 200 orders per month, 2 carriers, 1 origin, and 5 shipping rules; Standard lists up to 1,000 orders, 4 carriers, 4 origins, and 20 rules. Advanced lists 2,000 orders, 6 carriers, 8 origins, and 50 rules. Enterprise limits are custom. Duties and taxes, API access, and overage prices are not published, so get a quote before comparing total cost.
03Features and depth
Pirate Ship focuses on buying and managing labels. It compares discounted USPS and UPS rates, lets you choose a service, and print labels. It also lists bulk label printing, private label sharing, package tracking, and saved presets for frequently shipped packages. That covers common shipping tasks, but the published feature list does not describe checkout rate rules, delivery-date estimates, freight, or duties and taxes.
ShipperHQ is built around the checkout and shipping logic of an ecommerce store. It can show real-time rates and delivery dates, apply discounts or surcharges, set free-shipping conditions and restrictions, and calculate shipping from product dimensions, box sizes, and packing rules. Its feature list also includes LTL freight rates and accessorial fees, plus international duties and taxes with HS-code support. In short, Pirate Ship helps you compare rates and print labels; ShipperHQ gives stores more control over what shipping options shoppers see.
04Ease of use and learning curve
Pirate Ship has the simpler stated scope: compare USPS and UPS rates, choose a service, and print labels. Its review scores ease of use at 8 out of 10 and value at 9, while noting that savings and store integrations aren’t guaranteed. The source does not specify which integrations are available.
ShipperHQ gives merchants more settings to manage, including shipping rules, origins, packing logic, delivery dates, and carrier options. Its review describes configuration work as a factor to weigh and scores ease of use at 5.5. Plan limits also vary by tier, so confirm the order, carrier, origin, and rule caps for your platform before choosing. If you mainly need labels, ShipperHQ’s extra controls may be unnecessary; if checkout shipping needs rules, that added setup may be worth evaluating.
Questions people ask
Which is cheaper, Pirate Ship or ShipperHQ?
Pirate Ship has no monthly account fee, but you pay for postage and shipping labels. ShipperHQ’s prices are not published and vary by ecommerce platform; it offers a 15-day trial. Compare a ShipperHQ quote and any applicable overages with your actual shipping costs.
Can Pirate Ship show shipping rates at checkout?
The published Pirate Ship feature information lists rate comparison and label printing, but does not specify checkout rate controls. ShipperHQ explicitly lists real-time carrier rates and configurable checkout options. Confirm Pirate Ship’s current store integrations and checkout capabilities before switching.
Which one supports international duties and taxes?
ShipperHQ lists international duties and tax calculations at checkout, including HS-code support. The published Pirate Ship information covers discounted USPS and UPS rates and label tools, but does not specify duties or tax calculation features. Check each product’s current documentation for your destination markets.
Does ShipperHQ have a free plan?
The published pricing information lists no free ShipperHQ plan, but does list a 15-day trial. Prices are not published and vary by ecommerce platform. Pirate Ship’s Free Account has no monthly fee, though customers still pay for postage and shipping labels.