We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Paycom if you need HR and payroll in one system, employee self-service, and a dedicated support team. Choose TimeClock Plus if your priority is time collection, attendance, leave, and clock options, including hardware and K-12 tools. Neither publishes a starting price or offers a listed free plan, so get quotes before comparing value. Paycom says pricing varies by workforce size and modules; TimeClock Plus says pricing is quote-based. The better fit depends on whether you need broad HR or timekeeping.
01Side by side
| Paycom | TimeClock Plus | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | Custom quote; no starting rate published | Quote-based; no starting rate published |
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Best for | Organizations seeking customized HR software | Frontline time and attendance management |
| Core strength | HR and payroll in one database | Time, attendance, leave, and payroll calculations |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Integrations/data | Integrations not published; shared HR/payroll database | Integrations not published; captures time and attendance data |
| Team/seat costs | Quote varies by workforce size and modules | Per-seat rates and billing terms not published |
| Support | Dedicated implementation, payroll, and ongoing support team | Support model not published |
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want HR and payroll in one database.
- Choose Paycom if employee self-service matters.
- Choose Paycom if dedicated implementation and payroll support matters.
TimeClock Plus Choose TimeClock Plus if
- Choose TimeClock Plus if time collection is your priority.
- Choose TimeClock Plus if you need clock hardware options.
- Choose TimeClock Plus if you need K-12 attendance tools.
02Pricing compared
Neither vendor publishes a starting price in the published pricing information, and neither lists a free plan. A free trial is not listed either, so there’s no public entry price to use for a direct cost comparison.
Paycom says pricing is customized by workforce size and selected modules. Its listed options include payroll, talent acquisition, time and labor management, talent management, and HR management, but prices and the exact Core setup are not published. TimeClock Plus describes its pricing as quote-based; monthly and annual billing terms are not published, and no plan details are listed.
Get quotes based on the same headcount, locations, and required features. For Paycom, ask which modules are included. For TimeClock Plus, confirm what time-clock hardware and software are covered. Without those details, claims that one costs less aren’t supported by the published information.
03Features and depth
Paycom is the broader HR and payroll option. It keeps HR and payroll data in one database, automates payroll, and lets employees manage their own information. Beti builds payroll and lets employees find and fix errors before payroll runs. GONE automates time-off decisions, while IWant AI answers questions about employee profiles, applicant data, policies, and management dashboards. Paycom also lists a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing, and ongoing support.
TimeClock Plus is centered on time and attendance. It collects punches and tracks hours, breaks, leave, exceptions, accruals, overtime, job codes, and pay rates. It can automate payroll calculations and supports employee time-off requests with manager review and approval. Its clock options include on-site, mobile, and web clocks, alongside hardware. The product also lists K-12 attendance, extra-duty tracking, and absence-management tools.
The practical split is broad HR and payroll with Paycom versus more timekeeping and attendance options with TimeClock Plus.
04Ease of use and learning curve
The published reviews score Paycom 7/10 for ease of use and TimeClock Plus 6/10. Those ratings suggest a slight reported edge for Paycom, but they don’t establish how either system will feel for your team.
Paycom’s employee self-service and single database may suit organizations that want staff to manage HR and payroll details in one system. TimeClock Plus covers a range of timekeeping tasks and clock types, so buyers should check which tools their employees and managers will actually use. Neither product’s published information gives a learning timeline or training requirements. Ask both vendors to show the workflows relevant to your organization, including a time-off request and payroll preparation, before choosing.
Questions people ask
Who is Paycom’s biggest competitor?
The published information doesn’t identify Paycom’s biggest competitor, and that can depend on whether a buyer is comparing payroll, broader HR, or timekeeping. In this comparison, TimeClock Plus is the more focused time-and-attendance option; Paycom combines HR and payroll in one system.
What is the Paycom controversy?
The published product and review information doesn’t describe a specific Paycom controversy, so we can’t substantiate one here. It does note that Paycom’s pricing requires a quote and gives it a 4/10 user-sentiment score, but neither point establishes a controversy.
Is Paycom a good payroll system?
Paycom may fit organizations seeking automated payroll alongside HR tools and employee self-service. Beti lets employees find and fix errors before payroll runs, according to the published product details. The review scores features at 8/10, but value at 5/10; pricing is customized and not published.
Does Paycom track location when clocking in?
The published Paycom information doesn’t say whether it tracks an employee’s location when clocking in. It describes automated payroll, employee self-service, and time-off decisions, but gives no location-tracking details. Ask Paycom directly and confirm what location data is collected, when it is collected, and how it is used.