We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Employee Navigator for broker-led benefits administration, ACA reporting and benefits integrations; its prices are not published, so get a quote. GoCo may suit small and mid-sized businesses seeking HR workflows, payroll and time tracking, but the published price list is QuickBooks-branded and does not clearly establish GoCo HR pricing. Its free plan and seat limits may apply to QuickBooks, not GoCo HR. Treat the listed prices as a poor basis for comparing the two until GoCo confirms its current HR terms.
01Side by side
| Employee Navigator | GoCo | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | Quote only; plan prices not published | $19/month Simple Start; HR relevance unclear |
| Free plan | No free plan listed | QuickBooks Free listed; GoCo HR unclear |
| Best for | Brokers managing benefits administration | Small and mid-sized businesses needing HR tools |
| Core strength | Benefits administration, ACA reporting and payroll integrations | HR workflows, payroll and time tracking |
| Learning curve | Review ease score: 7 | Review ease score: 5 |
| Integrations and data | Homepage says 600+ integrations | Embedded payroll powered by Gusto |
| Team and seat costs | Unlimited companies and employees on select tiers; prices unpublished | QuickBooks seats capped at 1–25; HR relevance unclear |
| Support | Priority phone support on Platinum; other fees unpublished | Support details not published |
Employee Navigator Choose Employee Navigator if
- Choose Employee Navigator if broker-led benefits administration is central.
- Choose Employee Navigator if ACA reporting belongs in your benefits workflow.
- Choose Employee Navigator if you need benefits-focused integrations.
GoCo Choose GoCo if
- Choose GoCo if you need HR workflows for a smaller business.
- Choose GoCo if payroll and time tracking are key requirements.
- Choose GoCo if GoCo confirms its current HR pricing and plan limits.
02Pricing compared
Employee Navigator does not publish plan prices, monthly or annual billing, or the amounts for some add-on fees. Its plans run from Enhanced to Platinum, with features such as ACA reporting, onboarding, and priority phone support varying by tier. The pricing information lists 834 EDI at $0.45 per employee per month on Enhanced Plus and Elite, and free on Platinum; it is unavailable on Enhanced. Fees for 1095 and 1094 reporting and email and phone support are not published.
The published GoCo pricing list is QuickBooks-branded, so it does not establish GoCo HR pricing. It lists QuickBooks plans from $0 to $170 per month, but those prices and seat limits are a poor basis for comparing the HR products. Ask GoCo to confirm current HR pricing, limits, and any trial terms before switching.
03Features and depth
Employee Navigator is the clearer fit when benefits administration is the main job. Its feature set includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll, and third-party administrator integrations, ACA reporting, and, on higher plans, onboarding and time-off tracking. The pricing details also list AI Plan Builds on Enhanced, 834 EDI files on Enhanced Plus and above, and unlimited companies and employees on Enhanced Plus and Platinum. The homepage says it connects employers, brokers, and partners, with more than 600 integrations.
GoCo is positioned as HR and team-management software for small and midsized businesses. Its listed capabilities include HR workflows, payroll with an embedded setup powered by Gusto, time tracking, and team management. Intuit says it plans continued investment in onboarding, compliance, benefits, and performance workflows. That is not the same as a published feature-by-feature plan matrix: the published material does not clarify which GoCo HR features are included at each price or what limits apply. Compare those details directly before treating the products as equivalent.
04Ease of use and learning curve
Our review scores rate Employee Navigator higher for ease of use: 7 out of 10 versus GoCo at 5 out of 10. Those scores are a directional signal, not proof that setup or daily work will be easier for every team. Employee Navigator’s broker-led focus may make it a more natural fit for benefits administration, while GoCo’s HR workflows, payroll, and time tracking speak to a broader small-business toolkit.
Before switching, ask each vendor to walk through your actual tasks: enrollment, payroll handoffs, onboarding, and reporting. For GoCo, confirm current HR plan limits and terms; the provided QuickBooks prices do not answer those questions.
Questions people ask
Which is better for benefits administration?
Employee Navigator is the stronger match in the published information for broker-led benefits administration. Its plans list online enrollment, carrier and payroll integrations, ACA reporting, and higher-tier options such as onboarding. Get a quote first: plan prices and some fees are not published.
Does GoCo cost $19 per month?
The supplied $19 monthly price is for QuickBooks Simple Start, not a confirmed GoCo HR plan. The pricing details do not establish GoCo’s current HR price, seat limits, or billing terms. Ask GoCo for its current HR quote before comparing costs.
Does GoCo have a free plan or trial?
The published pricing information mentions QuickBooks Free and a 30-day trial, but it does not clearly tie either offer to GoCo HR. Do not assume they apply to GoCo. Confirm eligibility, included features, and what happens when a trial ends with the vendor.
Can Employee Navigator replace GoCo?
That depends on which workflows matter. Employee Navigator covers benefits administration, ACA reporting, integrations, and some HR tasks; GoCo is positioned around HR workflows, payroll, time tracking, and team management. Compare your required features and confirm GoCo’s current plan terms before deciding.