We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Big Cartel for a shop: it has a $0 Gold plan and paid plans at $15 and $30 per month, with tools for selling products. Choose Picsart for AI-assisted image, video, and audio creation; Pro is $15 monthly or $10.50 per month billed yearly. They solve different jobs, so neither replaces the other. Big Cartel fits selling products online; Picsart fits making creative assets. Picsart lists no free plan, while Big Cartel's free plan has limited, unspecified features.
01Side by side
| Big Cartel | Picsart | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $0/month Gold plan | $10.50/month, billed yearly |
| Free plan | Yes; features are limited and unspecified | No free plan listed |
| Best for | Independent sellers building an online shop | Creators making images, video, and audio |
| Core strength | Storefronts and product sales | AI-powered creative tools |
| Ease of use (review score) | 8 | 7 |
| Integrations and data | Imports from Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace; Diamond connects 7,000+ Zapier apps | Plugins for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Cursor; 168K+ assets |
| Team and seat costs | Seat pricing not published | Ultra extra-seat price not published |
| Support (review score) | 5 | 4 |
Big Cartel Choose Big Cartel if
- You need a free storefront for a small shop.
- You sell physical, digital, or print-on-demand products.
- You want product imports and online or in-person selling.
Picsart Choose Picsart if
- You need AI tools for image, video, or audio creation.
- You want creative workflows that connect models, effects, and assets.
- You need brand kits, bulk editing, or a large creative asset library.
02Pricing compared
These products charge for different jobs. Big Cartel has a $0 Gold plan, but its features are limited and the pricing details do not specify which features are included. Platinum is $15 per month and Diamond is $30 per month; annual prices are not listed on the vendor's site. The page also mentions a 7-day free period for paid plans.
Picsart lists no free plan. Pro costs $15 per month, or $10.50 per month when billed yearly. Ultra costs $75 per month, or $60 per month billed yearly. Ultra add-on credit and extra seat prices are not published. Big Cartel is the lower-cost option for a basic storefront; Picsart's paid plans are for creative work, not store management.
03Features and depth
Big Cartel is the store builder here. Its listed features cover physical and digital products, print-on-demand, custom domains, shipping labels, order tracking, design customization, and app installation. Diamond adds abandoned-cart recovery, scheduled product drops, password-protected products, and Zapier connections to 7,000+ apps. Sellers can connect to Instagram, Facebook, and Google Shopping, and accept cards, wallets, Venmo, and PayPal. The published information does not confirm a direct Printify integration.
Picsart is a creative platform, not a storefront. Its AI Playground generates and edits images, video, and audio, while Flow connects models, effects, and assets into workflows. Aura can select models and run steps from a text description. Pro includes 100 GB of storage and bulk edits for up to 50 images; Ultra lists 300 GB per seat and bulk edits for up to 100 images. Ultra also lists 200+ AI models. Its asset library is listed at 168K+.
04Ease of use and learning curve
Big Cartel describes its templates as customizable without coding, and Platinum includes easy-install apps. That makes the listed setup approach straightforward, though the published information does not spell out onboarding steps or migration limits. The review scored Big Cartel 8 for ease of use.
Picsart brings image, video, audio, AI models, and workflow tools into one platform. That range may suit creative users, but the source does not provide a learning-time estimate or setup details for Flow and Aura. The review scored Picsart 7 for ease of use. These are not direct substitutes: choose based on whether you need to sell products or make creative assets.
Questions people ask
Is Big Cartel a legit website?
Big Cartel is described here as an online store builder for independent sellers, with plans for listing products, managing sales, and accepting payments. The published information does not include independent security, reputation, or business-verification evidence, so it cannot establish a broader legitimacy assessment.
Who is Shopify's biggest competitor?
The published information does not compare Shopify with competitors or identify a market leader. Big Cartel does offer a store-building alternative for independent sellers, and its product-import feature lists Shopify among the supported sources. That does not establish that Big Cartel is Shopify's biggest competitor.
Does Big Cartel connect to Printify?
The published details say Big Cartel supports print-on-demand, but they do not confirm a direct Printify integration. Platinum includes easy-install apps, and Diamond lists Zapier connections to 7,000+ apps; neither detail specifically verifies Printify support.
Which is better, Etsy or Big Cartel?
They serve different selling approaches. Big Cartel provides a storefront and can import products from Etsy, but the review says it is not a substitute for marketplace discovery. Choose Big Cartel for an independent shop; the published information is not enough to compare Etsy's full features or fees.