We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Big Cartel works for a simple standalone shop, but it will not solve the traffic problem sellers describe on Reddit: a hosted storefront still needs customers brought to it. If you are leaving for more sales channels, choose Shopify; if discovery is the goal, consider Storenvy, but do not count on its marketplace listings as guaranteed buyers. Digital sellers may fit Payhip or Gumroad. Compare fees and plan limits before moving your catalog.
01Why people leave Big Cartel
You need marketplace discovery
Big Cartel hosts a storefront; it does not supply Etsy-style search discovery. Reddit sellers describe needing to drive traffic themselves.
You have outgrown the platform
One seller moved to Shopify after outgrowing Big Cartel; another thread warns Shopify fees can add up on small runs.
Your orders need more handling
For custom goods, one commenter recommends testing variants, personalization, shipping, and out-of-stock handling before committing.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for multichannel selling
ShopifyShopifyShopify is the clearest step up if you want to sell across multiple channels or need managed store operations and a large app ecosystem. Its listed starting price is $21, with a free plan listed too. A Reddit seller said they switched from Big Cartel after outgrowing it, though that is one seller’s account, not a guarantee the move will fit your shop.
Trade-off: Fees and app costs can make the convenience expensive.
7.2/10from
CHF 21/mofree plan - Best for marketplace listings
StorenvyStorenvyStorenvy is worth considering if you want a marketplace listing option alongside an independent shop. The listed starting price is $7.99, with a free plan. That makes it a closer fit than a pure storefront builder for sellers hoping to be found within a marketplace—but the listing option is not a promise of buyer traffic.
Trade-off: Bring your own traffic; don’t assume the marketplace will deliver buyers.
5.7/10from
$7.99/mofree plan - Best for store control
WooCommerceWooCommerceWooCommerce suits merchants who want checkout customization and a choice of hosting rather than a more packaged storefront. Its core is listed as free, and the platform supports selling across multiple channels. The trade is operational: hosting, extensions, and setup add cost and work, so compare those before treating a free core as a free store.
Trade-off: Hosting, extensions, and setup add cost and complexity.
7.1/10from
Freefree plan - Best for creator products
PayhipPayhipPayhip fits creators selling courses or memberships, or sellers who want to embed checkout on an existing website. It has a free plan and a listed starting price of $29, making it an option if you want to start without a subscription. Check the transaction fee against your sales volume before moving products over.
Trade-off: Weigh the transaction fee against your sales volume.
7.5/10from
$29/mofree plan - Best for digital products
GumroadGumroadGumroad is aimed at creators selling digital products, memberships, and subscriptions. It lists a free plan and no published starting price, which may suit sellers avoiding a monthly bill. The exchange is steep fees and doing your own marketing, so it is not an automatic fix for Big Cartel’s traffic problem.
Trade-off: Steep fees and your own marketing work.
6.3/10from
Freefree plan - Best for B2B and scale
BigCommerceBigCommerceBigCommerce is a better match than a simple shop builder if you need B2B account-specific pricing, cross-channel and cross-market selling, or API and code access. Its listed starting price is $29. Those capabilities may be more than a small independent shop needs, so check the plan’s gross merchandise volume limits and fees before switching.
Trade-off: Check gross merchandise volume limits and fees.
7.5/10from
$29/mo - Best for low-cost testing
CartpandaCartpandaCartpanda covers physical and digital products and accepts multiple currencies, which can make it worth a look for a small store testing online sales. It lists a free plan and a starting price of $0.99. That low entry figure is not the whole cost: account for its per-sale fees and weigh the mixed user feedback.
Trade-off: Per-sale fees and mixed user feedback warrant caution.
5.9/10from
$0.99/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Big Cartel Big Cartel (current) | 7.3 | $15/mo | Yes | Independent sellers building a standalone shop |
| Shopify Shopify | 7.2 | CHF 21/mo | Yes | Merchants selling across multiple channels |
| Storenvy Storenvy | 5.7 | $7.99/mo | Yes | New sellers testing a small catalog |
| WooCommerce WooCommerce | 7.1 | Free | Yes | Stores needing checkout customization |
| Payhip Payhip | 7.5 | $29/mo | Yes | Creators starting without a subscription |
| Gumroad Gumroad | 6.3 | Free | Yes | Creators selling digital products |
| BigCommerce BigCommerce | 7.5 | $29/mo | No | B2B sellers needing account-specific pricing |
| Cartpanda Cartpanda | 5.9 | $0.99/mo | Yes | Small stores testing online sales |
Questions people ask
Which Big Cartel alternative has marketplace listings?
Storenvy is the option in this list with a marketplace listing option. That may help if being listed in a marketplace matters, but it does not guarantee discovery or sales. Reddit sellers discussing Big Cartel describe needing to bring their own traffic, so do not switch expecting marketplace listings alone to solve that.
What is the cheapest Big Cartel alternative?
There is no clean winner from entry prices alone: several options list free plans, while their fees and included limits differ. Cartpanda lists a $0.99 starting price, Storenvy $7.99, and Payhip $29. Gumroad has a free plan but no published starting price. Compare transaction fees and plan limits too.
Should I switch from Big Cartel to Shopify?
Shopify is a reasonable candidate if you need multiple sales channels, managed store operations, or a large app ecosystem. Its listed starting price is $21, with a free plan listed. But the pricing summary warns that fees and app costs can add up; a Reddit commenter also cautioned that Shopify fees can weigh on small runs.