We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Big Cartel.
Choose Big Cartel for a low-cost storefront for an independent shop: its Gold plan is free, and Platinum is listed at $15/month. Choose Ecwid if you want to sell through an existing website, marketplaces, social channels, mobile, and in person. Ecwid’s published pricing notes list Starter at $5/month for up to 10 products, but that price information is low-confidence. Annual rates and staff-seat pricing are not listed. Big Cartel’s free plan has limited features, with details not provided.
01Side by side
| Big Cartel | Ecwid | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | Gold is free; paid plans start at $15/month | Starter listed at $5/month; low-confidence pricing |
| Free plan | Gold is free, with limited unspecified features | No free plan listed |
| Best for | Independent sellers wanting a simple storefront | Small stores adding commerce to a website |
| Core strength | Simple shop for physical and digital goods | Multichannel selling and store management |
| Learning curve | Customize storefront without coding | Build a store or add one to a site |
| Integrations/data | Imports Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace; Diamond connects Zapier | Sell through websites, marketplaces, social, mobile, in-person |
| Team/seat costs | Staff-seat details and pricing not listed | Staff accounts; seat pricing not listed |
| Support | Published review support score: 5/10 | Published review support score: 4.5/10 |
Big Cartel Choose Big Cartel if
- Choose Big Cartel if you need a free, limited storefront.
- Choose Big Cartel if you sell physical or digital goods.
- Choose Big Cartel if you want scheduled drops on Diamond.
Ecwid Choose Ecwid if
- Choose Ecwid if you sell across multiple channels.
- Choose Ecwid if you need staff accounts.
- Choose Ecwid if you already have a website to add a store.
02Pricing compared
Big Cartel has the clearer low-cost entry point: its Gold plan is free, though the published pricing details don’t say what features it includes. Platinum is listed at $15 per month and Diamond at $30 per month. The pricing notes also mention a 7-day free period for paid plans. Annual prices aren’t provided.
Ecwid’s published pricing notes list Starter at $5 per month for up to 10 products. That information is marked low-confidence, so confirm the price and cap with Ecwid before switching. The notes don’t list other Ecwid plans, annual rates, a free plan, or a trial. Neither source provides staff-seat pricing. In short, Big Cartel’s free plan may suit a small shop willing to accept unspecified limits; Ecwid’s listed Starter plan has a clear 10-product cap, but its price needs verification.
03Features and depth
Big Cartel focuses on a storefront for independent sellers. It supports physical and digital goods, print-on-demand, discounts, scheduled product drops, and password-protected products on Diamond. Platinum includes custom domains, shipping labels, order tracking, design customization, and easy-install apps. Big Cartel also lists imports from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace, plus connections to Instagram, Facebook, and Google Shopping. Diamond includes Zapier connections to 7,000+ apps.
Ecwid’s published feature list emphasizes selling across channels: an existing website or a new store, marketplaces, social media, mobile, and in person. It also lists inventory, order, pricing, and staff-account management, along with automated emails, scheduled discounts, ad tools, payment and shipping features, and ecommerce reports. That makes Ecwid the better fit on paper for a seller who needs broad channel and store-management tools. Big Cartel is more specifically positioned around a straightforward independent shop. The published details don’t establish feature-by-feature parity between the platforms.
04Ease of use and learning curve
Big Cartel says sellers can customize templates without coding, and the review describes it as a good-value option for a simple independent shop. Its limited free-plan features aren’t detailed, so check whether Gold covers your selling needs before building around it.
Ecwid can be added to an existing website or used to build a new store with themes and content blocks. Its broader list of channels and management tools may mean more settings to configure, but the published material doesn’t document setup time or learning requirements. The reviews score Big Cartel’s ease of use at 8 and Ecwid’s at 7; those are review scores, not measured setup results. Choose based on the setup you need: a focused storefront or a store connected to more sales channels.
Questions people ask
Is Big Cartel a legit website?
Big Cartel is described in the published material as an online store builder for independent sellers, with storefronts, product listings, and sales management. That doesn’t verify any individual shop or seller. Before buying, check the seller’s policies and contact details, and use a payment method with buyer protections.
Is Ecwid like Shopify?
They overlap as ecommerce tools: the published material says Ecwid can build or add a store and manage sales, while Big Cartel supports importing products from Shopify. The sources don’t provide enough information to compare Ecwid and Shopify’s plans, features, or limits directly.
Does Big Cartel connect to Printify?
The published material says Big Cartel supports print-on-demand and that Platinum includes easy-install apps; Diamond adds Zapier connections to 7,000+ apps. It doesn’t specifically confirm a Printify integration, so check Big Cartel’s current app listings or ask support before relying on that connection.
Which is better, Big Cartel or Shopify?
The published details aren’t enough to name a universal winner: they don’t compare Shopify’s current pricing or features. Big Cartel is positioned for a simple independent shop and can import products from Shopify. Compare your required features and the current plan limits before switching.