We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Printful has a free plan and broad channel integrations, but its listed starting price is $24.99. Sellers considering a switch cite cost, delivery delays and quality concerns, though Reddit reports are mixed: some describe years of reliable orders. For a like-for-like POD comparison, start with Printify, Gelato, Gooten, CustomCat or Merchize. EPROLO is a broader dropshipping option, not a direct POD match. Compare the listed starting prices, then check product and shipping costs before moving your catalog.
01Why people leave Printful
Margins feel too tight
One Reddit commenter called Printful more expensive than most providers and said high sales volume was needed to make it viable. That is one seller’s view, not a margin guarantee.
Delivery complaints
In one Reddit thread, a seller reported delays and lost packages, alongside longer fulfillment times. Other commenters describe consistent delivery, so experiences vary.
Quality concerns
Some sellers in a Reddit thread reported quality issues; others praised their products and printing. If quality is your reason to leave, compare samples before moving orders.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best direct comparison
PrintifyPrintifyPrintify is a natural first comparison if you want to stay with print-on-demand rather than change business models. Its listing includes a free plan, a $24.99 starting price, a large catalog and broad integrations. Those fit sellers testing products or selling across channels. The stated caveat is fulfillment consistency, so switching does not remove the need to check supplier performance.
Trade-off: Fulfillment consistency is the main stated concern.
6.7/10from
$24.99/mofree plan - Best for local production
GelatoGelatoGelato is worth comparing if local production is part of your reason for leaving Printful. Its listing names local production, Shopify and Etsy sellers, and new POD sellers as a fit; it has a free plan and starts at $19.99. The summary advises checking order costs and seller feedback, so compare landed costs rather than the starting price alone.
Trade-off: Order costs and seller feedback need checking.
7.0/10from
$19.99/mofree plan - Best without monthly fees
GootenGootenGooten may suit merchants who want to test POD without a monthly fee. Its listing describes a broad product catalog and store integrations, while the listed plan is free and the starting price is n/a. That makes it a useful comparison if Printful’s recurring price is the sticking point, but the summary recommends keeping a backup supplier.
Trade-off: Keep a backup supplier; starting price is not listed.
5.5/10from
Freefree plan - Best for cost comparison
CustomCatCustomCatCustomCat is another direct POD option to compare when Printful’s economics are the concern. The listing shows a free plan, a $25 starting price, a broad product catalog and a fit for businesses comparing wholesale fulfillment costs. Its summary specifically says to compare landed costs before moving, so price the actual products and orders you sell.
Trade-off: Compare landed costs, not just plan prices.
6.8/10from
$25/mofree plan - Best for catalog breadth
MerchizeMerchizeMerchize may fit sellers looking for a broad POD catalog, multichannel integrations or global production options. Its listing includes a free plan and starts at $79, which is higher than the listed starting prices for Printify and Gelato. The summary advises checking fees and workflow before committing, so it is a comparison candidate, not an automatic cost-saving move.
Trade-off: Higher listed starting price; check fees and workflow.
6.8/10from
$79/mofree plan - Best for branded dropshipping
EPROLOEPROLOEPROLO is an adjacent option if you are open to broader dropshipping rather than seeking a like-for-like POD provider. Its listing highlights order syncing, fulfillment and custom branding, with a free plan and a $1.66 starting price. The summary warns that product, shipping and branding costs can make order economics hard to pin down.
Trade-off: Not a direct POD match; costs can be hard to pin down.
6.9/10from
$1.66/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Printful Printful (current) | 7.0 | $24.99/mo | Yes | New sellers testing product ideas |
| Printify Printify | 6.7 | $24.99/mo | Yes | New print-on-demand sellers |
| Gelato Gelato | 7.0 | $19.99/mo | Yes | Sellers starting with print-on-demand |
| Gooten Gooten | 5.5 | Free | Yes | Merchants testing print-on-demand without monthly fees |
| CustomCat CustomCat | 6.8 | $25/mo | Yes | Sellers starting with print-on-demand |
| Merchize Merchize | 6.8 | $79/mo | Yes | Sellers wanting a broad POD catalog |
| EPROLO EPROLO | 6.9 | $1.66/mo | Yes | New dropshippers testing product ideas |
Questions people ask
Which Printful alternative has the lowest listed starting price?
Among these picks, EPROLO has the lowest listed starting figure at $1.66, with a free plan. Gelato starts at $19.99, Printify at $24.99, CustomCat at $25 and Merchize at $79. Gooten is listed as n/a. These figures alone do not establish the cost of fulfilling your orders.
Is Printful’s quality consistently bad?
The Reddit reports provided do not support a simple yes. Some sellers describe quality or fulfillment problems, while others report consistent quality, delivery and customer service. Treat those posts as individual experiences, not a measured failure rate. If quality is your reason to switch, compare samples before moving your orders.
What should I check before switching from Printful?
Compare the products you sell, plan fees, product and shipping costs, and the integrations your store needs. The alternatives’ summaries flag order costs, landed costs, fees or workflow as things to check. Also consider a backup supplier: Gooten’s listing explicitly recommends keeping one.