We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
NetBird’s strongest draw is self-hosted control; Reddit users who moved to it from Tailscale cite control of the coordination plane and open-source software. The Reddit threads we read mostly discuss switching to NetBird, not leaving it. They do flag tradeoffs: some users find its exit-node flow clunkier, and one says high availability requires an enterprise license. For a like-for-like private-networking alternative, start with ZeroTier. The other picks suit a change in networking or security approach, not a direct swap.
01Why people leave NetBird
Self-hosting is no longer a priority
NetBird’s self-hosted control plane is a draw for some Reddit users. If you don’t need that control, compare managed networking or access options instead.
The access workflow feels clunky
One Reddit commenter says NetBird’s exit-node flow is less convenient than Tailscale’s. That’s a reported tradeoff, not a universal verdict.
You need high availability
One Reddit user says NetBird HA requires an enterprise license; they add that it can be implemented in the open-source version, but is harder.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Private network replacement
ZeroTierZeroTierZeroTier is the closest fit here if you want to replace NetBird’s private-networking role rather than move to a firewall or security suite. Its listed use cases include replacing complex VPN setups and air-gapped networking. The pricing summary lists a free plan and an $18 starting price; personal use is capped at 10 devices.
Trade-off: The listed personal-use limit is 10 devices, and the starting price is higher than NetBird’s.
7.4/10from
$18/mofree plan - VPN and VPC networking
pfSense PluspfSense PlusConsider pfSense Plus if you’re changing from an overlay network to a firewall deployment with VPN and VPC connectivity. The listed fit includes Netgate appliance buyers and AWS or Azure firewall deployments. It has a free plan and starts at $10.75, but it is a different kind of network tool—not a like-for-like NetBird replacement.
Trade-off: Check the full bill and upgrade terms before committing.
6.7/10from
$10.75/mofree plan - Commercial firewall firmware
OPNsense Business EditionOPNsense Business EditionOPNsense Business Edition fits teams that want a commercial firmware repository, are considering OPNcentral for multiple installations, or need included security features. It may make sense if your reason for leaving NetBird is a move toward business firewall operations. The listed starting price is $11.08; the published information does not describe it as a mesh VPN replacement.
Trade-off: It costs $11.08 to start and serves a different role from NetBird.
7.3/10from
€11.08/mo - Private app access
Zscaler Zero Trust ExchangeZscaler Zero Trust ExchangeZscaler Zero Trust Exchange is worth evaluating if your goal is securing private app access as part of a broader zero-trust setup, rather than preserving a self-hosted overlay network. Its listed use cases also include consolidating zero-trust controls and protecting AI deployments. Pricing is not published, and the summary flags meaningful access limits.
Trade-off: Pricing is not published, and access limits need checking.
6.3/10from
Custom - Enterprise firewall deployments
Check Point Quantum Security GatewaysCheck Point Quantum Security GatewaysCheck Point Quantum Security Gateways suit enterprises looking for hardware firewalls across hybrid on-premises and cloud environments. This is a substantial change in approach from NetBird’s self-hosted access model, so consider it when firewall infrastructure—not just private device connectivity—is the actual requirement. Pricing is quote-only, and public product detail is limited.
Trade-off: Quote-only pricing and limited public detail make costs harder to compare.
6.5/10from
Custom - Distributed DDI management
BlueCat EdgeBlueCat EdgeBlueCat Edge is a possible fit if you’re leaving NetBird because the problem has shifted to managing DNS, DHCP and IP address services across cloud and on-premises environments. The listed use cases include connecting remote branches and automating DDI through APIs. It is not presented as an overlay VPN, and pricing and limits are opaque.
Trade-off: Pricing and limits are not published; it is not a direct overlay-network substitute.
5.8/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 NetBird NetBird (current) | 7.8 | €6/mo | Yes | Homelabs seeking self-hosted access |
| ZeroTier ZeroTier | 7.4 | $18/mo | Yes | Teams replacing complex VPN setups |
| pfSense Plus pfSense Plus | 6.7 | $10.75/mo | Yes | Netgate appliance buyers |
| OPNsense Business Edition OPNsense Business Edition | 7.3 | €11.08/mo | No | Teams wanting a commercial firmware repository |
| Zscaler Zero Trust Exchange Zscaler Zero Trust Exchange | 6.3 | Custom | No | Organizations consolidating zero trust controls |
| Check Point Quantum Security Gateways Check Point Quantum Security Gateways | 6.5 | Custom | No | Enterprises seeking hardware firewalls |
| BlueCat Edge BlueCat Edge | 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams managing DDI across cloud and on-premises |
Questions people ask
What is the closest NetBird alternative?
Among these picks, ZeroTier is the closest fit for replacing private networking: its listed use cases include replacing complex VPN setups. Its pricing summary shows a free plan, an $18 starting price and a 10-device limit for personal users. The published details do not establish feature parity with NetBird.
Why do people leave NetBird?
The Reddit threads we read mainly discuss switching from Tailscale to NetBird, so they are not strong evidence of why people leave NetBird. They do mention a clunkier exit-node flow and a reported enterprise-license requirement for high availability. Those are possible reasons to reassess, not proof of widespread churn.
How much does NetBird cost compared with ZeroTier?
Our comparison lists NetBird from $6 with a free plan and ZeroTier from $18 with a free plan. It does not specify the billing unit or give a full feature-by-feature plan comparison. ZeroTier’s listed personal-use cap is 10 devices, so check the current pricing pages before switching.