We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
If you’re reconsidering INKY after its Kaseya acquisition, start by comparing security fit and contract terms—not just the headline price. Reddit users report concerns about support, billing, and service quality, but those are individual accounts, not a measure of every customer’s experience. Our shortlist covers six alternatives with different strengths, from API-connected email security to healthcare-focused tools. Several listings do not publish prices, so ask vendors to put seat minimums, renewal terms, support commitments, and exit conditions in writing.
01Why people leave INKY
Concerns after the Kaseya acquisition
An r/msp poster said their team reconsidered after Kaseya acquired INKY, citing prior friction with contracts, billing, support responsiveness, and service quality.
Reports of weaker support
One Reddit thread says support went from top-notch to nearly nonexistent after the acquisition; that is a user report, not a verified service-wide trend.
Contract and migration uncertainty
An MSP commenter advises checking tenant management, alert routing, renewal terms, seat minimums, price holds, support SLAs, and mid-term downgrades before switching.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- API-connected security
AvananAvananAvanan is a strong shortlist option if you want email security rather than a general-purpose mailbox: its listing highlights API-connected protection, SaaS file and chat inspection, and post-delivery remediation. One r/msp commenter called it “fantastic.” The catch is procurement: its price and limits are not published on the vendor's site, so get both, along with support and renewal terms, in writing.
Trade-off: Price and limits are not published.
6.7/10from
Custom - Broad security coverage
ProofpointProofpointProofpoint suits buyers who want broad security coverage plus data and AI controls, rather than choosing on entry price alone. Its listing starts at $2.75, but the published summary says enterprise terms need negotiation. If you are leaving over Kaseya-related contract or billing friction, compare renewal, minimum-seat, and exit terms before you sign.
Trade-off: Enterprise pricing and terms require negotiation.
6.0/10from
$2.75/mo - Lower listed starting price
Proofpoint EssentialsProofpoint EssentialsProofpoint Essentials is the lowest-listed-price option in this shortlist, starting at $1.65, and is aimed at business email security; its listing also notes Active Directory onboarding. It may suit teams whose main goal is a lower-cost filter, but the entry price has an eligibility catch and reports are mixed. Confirm eligibility and total contract cost before treating it as cheaper than INKY.
Trade-off: The entry price has an eligibility catch.
6.2/10from
$1.65/mo - Behavioral BEC detection
Abnormal AIAbnormal AIAbnormal AI is worth evaluating if your specific concern is business email compromise: its listing focuses on behavioral BEC detection and also names identity security and AI governance. It is not an easy cost comparison with INKY because pricing is not published on the vendor's site. The stated URL-phishing trade-off is worth checking against your existing controls.
Trade-off: URL-phishing trade-offs need evaluation.
6.2/10from
Custom - Healthcare email workflows
PauboxPauboxPaubox is a better fit for healthcare teams using Google or Microsoft email than for buyers seeking a general-purpose INKY replacement. Its listing combines email with forms and offers inbound security or archiving options. The price is not published on the vendor's site, and the plan has a five-sender limit, so confirm that limit fits your team before comparing costs.
Trade-off: Unpublished prices; five-sender plan limit.
6.8/10from
Custom - Encrypted email and files
VirtruVirtruVirtru makes more sense if your priority is encrypted email and attachments, or adding secure file workflows, rather than matching every part of INKY’s broad email protection. Its listing starts at $119 and names compliance features for regulated teams. The entry price is steep, and limited price transparency makes it important to confirm what the quoted package includes.
Trade-off: Steep listed entry price; limited price transparency.
6.0/10from
$119/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 INKY INKY (current) | 6.6 | Custom | No | Organizations needing broad email protection |
| Avanan Avanan | 6.7 | Custom | No | Teams seeking API-connected email security |
| Proofpoint Proofpoint | 6.0 | $2.75/mo | No | Small businesses seeking email security |
| Proofpoint Essentials Proofpoint Essentials | 6.2 | $1.65/mo | No | Existing Essentials customers seeking lower pricing |
| Abnormal AI Abnormal AI | 6.2 | Custom | No | Teams prioritizing behavioral BEC detection |
| Paubox Paubox | 6.8 | Custom | No | Healthcare teams using Google or Microsoft email |
| Virtru Virtru | 6.0 | $119/mo | No | Teams needing encrypted email and attachments |
Questions people ask
Which INKY alternative should we evaluate first?
For an email-security shortlist, Avanan is worth evaluating for its API-connected protection and post-delivery remediation, while Proofpoint and Proofpoint Essentials offer broader security coverage or a lower listed starting price. Match the choice to your requirements, then verify pricing, limits, support, and contract terms directly with the vendor.
Which alternatives publish a starting price?
Among these picks, Proofpoint Essentials lists a starting price of $1.65, Proofpoint $2.75, and Virtru $119. The pricing page do not publish prices for Avanan, Abnormal AI, or Paubox. These figures do not establish your total contract cost; confirm eligibility, seat minimums, term, and renewal pricing.
What should we check before migrating from INKY?
An MSP commenter on Reddit recommends checking tenant management and alert routing, then getting renewal terms, minimum seats, price holds, support SLAs, and mid-term downgrade rules in writing. Also confirm that the alternative covers your specific needs, such as impersonation or malware protection, before you commit.