We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Gelato is listed at $19.99 with a free plan, but its own summary says to check order costs and seller feedback before switching. One r/printondemand post says the seller found few reviews when researching Gelato; a commenter says the service may have improved. That is a reason to investigate, not proof of a current problem. For direct POD comparisons, start with Printify, Printful, CustomCat, Merchize and Gooten; look at EPROLO or Cloudprinter.com for different fulfillment needs.
01Why people leave Gelato
Order economics need checking
Gelato’s listing advises checking order costs; the Reddit post says its author chose Gelato partly because prices looked low, not that total costs stayed low.
Few reviews to compare
The r/printondemand author says they found a low quantity of reviews. A commenter says Gelato may have improved, so treat the post as a prompt to verify.
Mixed signals on service
The available post is negative, but its account is incomplete and a commenter mentions possible improvements. Check current seller feedback before moving a catalog.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- New POD sellers
PrintifyPrintifyPrintify is the closest straightforward comparison if you want to keep a print-on-demand model while testing products and store integrations. Its listing highlights a large catalog and broad integrations, with a free plan and a $24.99 starting price. That gives you a clear alternative to price against Gelato’s listed $19.99 entry point.
Trade-off: The listing flags fulfillment consistency as the main concern.
6.7/10from
$24.99/mofree plan - Broad channel integrations
PrintfulPrintfulPrintful suits sellers who want a broad POD toolkit and channel integrations rather than choosing on starting price alone. It has a free plan and a listed starting price of $24.99, above Gelato’s $19.99 figure. Its stated fit includes new sellers testing ideas and brands seeking POD fulfillment.
Trade-off: It costs more to start, and the listing flags margin and fulfillment concerns.
7.0/10from
$24.99/mofree plan - Catalog breadth
CustomCatCustomCatCustomCat is worth comparing if you want a broad product catalog and are weighing wholesale fulfillment costs. The listing gives it a free plan and a $25 starting price, making the listed entry point higher than Gelato’s. Compare the landed order costs before moving products or changing your storefront workflow.
Trade-off: The listed starting price is higher; compare landed costs.
6.8/10from
$25/mofree plan - Global production options
MerchizeMerchizeMerchize is aimed at sellers who need catalog variety, multichannel integrations or global production options. It has a free plan, but its listed starting price is $79, well above Gelato’s $19.99. It makes more sense to investigate for those specific needs than as a cheaper replacement.
Trade-off: Higher listed starting price; fees and workflow need checking.
6.8/10from
$79/mofree plan - No monthly fee
GootenGootenGooten is an option if avoiding a monthly fee matters more than having a published starting price. Its listing says it has a $0 monthly fee, a broad product catalog and listed store integrations; the starting price is shown as n/a. The listing recommends keeping a backup supplier.
Trade-off: No published starting price; keep a backup supplier.
5.5/10from
Freefree plan - Custom-brand dropshipping
EPROLOEPROLOEPROLO is a broader dropshipping alternative for sellers who want order syncing, fulfillment and custom-branding options. Its listing shows a free plan and a $1.66 starting price, lower than Gelato’s listed entry point. It may fit a store testing products beyond a print-on-demand catalog.
Trade-off: Product, shipping and branding costs can complicate order economics.
6.9/10from
$1.66/mofree plan - International print routing
Cloudprinter.comCloudprinter.comCloudprinter.com is a more specialized option for teams routing print orders internationally, using multiple routing profiles or automating print workflows. The listing includes a free plan and a $199 starting price. It is a poor fit if you simply want a lower-cost replacement, but relevant if routing controls are the priority.
Trade-off: Higher listed starting price; key plan and Enterprise details are unclear.
6.8/10from
€199/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Gelato Gelato (current) | 7.0 | $19.99/mo | Yes | Sellers starting with print-on-demand |
| Printify Printify | 6.7 | $24.99/mo | Yes | New print-on-demand sellers |
| Printful Printful | 7.0 | $24.99/mo | Yes | New sellers testing product ideas |
| CustomCat CustomCat | 6.8 | $25/mo | Yes | Sellers starting with print-on-demand |
| Merchize Merchize | 6.8 | $79/mo | Yes | Sellers wanting a broad POD catalog |
| Gooten Gooten | 5.5 | Free | Yes | Merchants testing print-on-demand without monthly fees |
| EPROLO EPROLO | 6.9 | $1.66/mo | Yes | New dropshippers testing product ideas |
| Cloudprinter.com Cloudprinter.com | 6.8 | €199/mo | Yes | Teams routing print orders internationally |
Questions people ask
Which Gelato alternative has the lowest listed starting price?
Among these picks, EPROLO has the lowest listed starting figure at $1.66 and includes a free plan. That is not a landed order-cost comparison: its listing warns that product, shipping and branding costs can make the economics hard to pin down.
Is Printify a direct alternative to Gelato?
Yes, both listings describe print-on-demand options. Printify’s listed fit includes new POD sellers and stores testing products, with a broad catalog, broad integrations, a free plan and a $24.99 starting price. Its listing flags fulfillment consistency as a concern to weigh.
Does Reddit prove Gelato is a bad choice?
No. The published r/printondemand post is negative, but the available account is incomplete. The author says they found few reviews, while a commenter says Gelato may have improved. Use that thread as a reason to check current seller feedback, not as proof of current service quality.