We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
For a like-for-like DNS-filtering shortlist, NextDNS is the clearest fit among these alternatives; the others cover adjacent needs such as DDI, school filtering, firewalls or broader security. Cisco Umbrella’s price is not listed in our comparison, so compare written renewal quotes against scope—not just headline price. One small-business Reddit poster reported paying about $1,500 a year, but that is one buyer’s account, not a market rate. Check client counts and roaming coverage before switching.
01Why people leave Cisco Umbrella
Renewal is a buying trigger
One r/msp thread began with a contract renewal; a small-business poster separately reported about $1,500/year and was shopping before a May renewal.
Redirect behavior can frustrate users
One engineer said Umbrella’s injected redirect broke developer tooling and sites with strict content-security policies; commenters questioned whether that behavior is default.
Pricing and documentation are unclear
Our comparison lists Cisco Umbrella pricing as unavailable and flags thin product-specific documentation, making scope and total-cost checks important.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Configurable DNS filtering
NextDNSNextDNSNextDNS is the closest fit here if the job is configurable DNS filtering rather than a full secure-access stack. The comparison lists a free plan and a $2.325 starting price. A Reddit user shopping from Umbrella said NextDNS handled the domain-blocking features they wanted; another commenter pointed to machine-level filtering in the dashboard and logs. Treat those as user reports, not a feature guarantee.
Trade-off: It is positioned for households; Reddit commenters raised concerns about support and development activity.
8.2/10from
CA$2.33/mofree plan - DDI across environments
BlueCat EdgeBlueCat EdgeBlueCat Edge is worth considering if your switch is part of a broader DDI project, not just a change to DNS-layer security. The comparison positions it for cloud and on-premises DDI, remote branches and API automation. That may fit teams consolidating network infrastructure across sites, but confirm which DNS security controls and limits are included before treating it as an Umbrella replacement.
Trade-off: Pricing and limits are opaque, so request a scoped quote before comparing value.
5.8/10from
Custom - School filtering
LinewizeLinewizeLinewize is the more relevant option if you are leaving Umbrella in a school environment and want filtering alongside classroom controls. The comparison describes it as a broad school safety suite, with responsive support as a stated strength. Ask for a quote and confirm Windows and VPN coverage against your current deployment before planning a migration.
Trade-off: Pricing is not listed; verify Windows and VPN coverage before switching.
7.4/10from
Custom - Broader security platform
Zscaler Cloud IPSZscaler Cloud IPSZscaler Cloud IPS fits organizations already evaluating Zscaler or looking beyond DNS-layer protection to a broader security platform. It is a reasonable shortlist candidate when Umbrella renewal prompts a wider internet-access review. The comparison says pricing is quote-based; ask Zscaler to define Cloud IPS scope and included services in writing before comparing it with Umbrella.
Trade-off: The comparison lists no price, and Cloud IPS scope should be confirmed in writing.
5.5/10from
Custom - Enterprise firewall
Check Point Quantum Security GatewaysCheck Point Quantum Security GatewaysCheck Point Quantum Security Gateways suit enterprises that are considering a hardware firewall rather than seeking a direct DNS-filtering substitute. The comparison lists hybrid on-premises and cloud environments among its best-fit uses. If the Umbrella review is part of a network-security redesign, compare the specific subscription scope and deployment requirements against your current controls.
Trade-off: It is an enterprise firewall option with quote-only pricing and limited public detail.
6.5/10from
Custom - Firewall and VPN needs
pfSense PluspfSense PluspfSense Plus is a fit if your Umbrella change is bundled with firewall, VPN or cloud-networking work. The comparison lists Netgate appliances and AWS or Azure firewall deployments, plus VPN and VPC connectivity. It has a free plan and a listed starting price of $10.75, but confirm the full bill and upgrade terms before comparing costs.
Trade-off: Check the complete bill and upgrade terms; it is a broader network tool, not a direct DNS match.
6.7/10from
$10.75/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Cisco Umbrella Cisco Umbrella (current) | 5.2 | Custom | No | Teams seeking DNS-layer security |
| NextDNS NextDNS | 8.2 | CA$2.33/mo | Yes | Households filtering traffic across devices |
| BlueCat Edge BlueCat Edge | 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams managing DDI across cloud and on-premises |
| Linewize Linewize | 7.4 | Custom | No | Districts wanting a broad safety suite |
| Zscaler Cloud IPS Zscaler Cloud IPS | 5.5 | Custom | No | Organizations already considering Zscaler |
| Check Point Quantum Security Gateways Check Point Quantum Security Gateways | 6.5 | Custom | No | Enterprises seeking hardware firewalls |
| pfSense Plus pfSense Plus | 6.7 | $10.75/mo | Yes | Netgate appliance buyers |
Questions people ask
Which alternative is closest to Cisco Umbrella for DNS filtering?
NextDNS is the closest fit among the alternatives listed here because it is described as configurable DNS filtering. A Reddit user shopping for a replacement said its domain-blocking features met their needs, while another commenter cited machine-level filtering in the dashboard and logs. Those reports are individual experiences, not a guarantee of equivalent coverage.
How much does Cisco Umbrella cost compared with these alternatives?
Cisco Umbrella pricing is not listed in our comparison. One small-business Reddit poster reported paying about $1,500 per year, but that is a single account, not a standard price. The comparison lists NextDNS at $2.325 with a free plan and pfSense Plus at $10.75 with a free plan; it does not state billing periods.
What should schools check before leaving Umbrella?
Linewize is listed for school filtering and classroom controls, but its price is not published in our comparison. Before switching, request a quote and verify Windows and VPN coverage, which the comparison specifically flags for buyers to confirm. Also compare the proposed filtering scope with the controls your school currently relies on.