We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Substack if the product is a publication: it offers free publishing, unlimited subscribers and sending, and says you retain your mailing list and intellectual property. Choose Patreon if you want memberships, exclusive work, online shops, and fan-community tools such as group chats and DMs. Neither lists a monthly subscription price, and both take 10% on paid earnings; payment processing or other applicable fees can add to the cost.
01Side by side
| Substack | Patreon | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $0/month; 10% of paid subscription revenue | No upfront cost; 10% of income earned |
| Free plan | Free platform; unlimited subscribers, sending, and posts | No upfront cost; pay when earning |
| Best for | Publishing work and building a mailing list | Memberships and fan communities |
| Core strength | Publishing, subscriptions, and editorial control | Memberships, shops, and community tools |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Integrations / data | Mailing-list ownership; integration details not published | Fan analytics; integration details not published |
| Team / seat costs | Seat costs not published | Seat costs not published |
| Support | Review support score: 5/10 | Review support score: 5/10 |
Substack Choose Substack if
- Choose Substack if you want free publishing with unlimited subscribers.
- Choose Substack if mailing-list and intellectual-property ownership matter.
- Choose Substack if editorial control without gatekeepers is a priority.
Patreon Choose Patreon if
- Choose Patreon if you want ongoing memberships and exclusive work.
- Choose Patreon if you want online shops for individual works.
- Choose Patreon if fan chats, comments, and DMs matter.
02Pricing compared
Neither platform lists a monthly subscription price, and both offer a free plan. Substack’s listed platform cost is $0 per month, with unlimited subscribers, sending, and posts; free newsletters, podcasts, and video are included. It takes 10% of subscription revenue when you charge. US card payments typically add Stripe’s 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction and a 0.7% recurring billing fee. A custom domain is a $50 one-time add-on. Patreon lists no upfront cost and takes 10% of income earned on Patreon. Payment processing, currency conversion, payout fees, and applicable taxes may also apply, but their amounts are not published. The headline rates match, but the total can differ by payment method and added fees; compare those costs with your expected paid revenue before switching.
03Features and depth
Substack combines publishing, paid subscriptions, and mailing-list features. The platform says publishers retain ownership of their mailing lists and intellectual property, and can publish with editorial control. Its free plan includes newsletters, podcasts, video, unlimited subscribers, and unlimited sending and posts. A feed and discussion features connect readers and creators.
Patreon is more focused on memberships and fan relationships. Creators can share exclusive videos, podcasts, writing, art, music, recipes, and other work; sell individual items through online shops; and connect with fans through group chats, comments, DMs, and email. Patreon also lists fan analytics and relationship-management tools.
Choose based on the product you want to build: Substack’s listed features suit a publication that needs email publishing and paid subscriptions, while Patreon lists more membership, shop, and community tools. The published details do not establish that either platform replaces every feature of the other.
04Ease of use and learning curve
The published information does not provide a direct usability comparison, so we would not call one platform easier based on these details alone. The simpler fit depends on what you need to set up. Substack brings publishing, mailing lists, and paid subscriptions together, with unlimited subscribers and sending on its free plan. Patreon’s listed toolkit covers memberships, exclusive work, shops, community channels, analytics, and fan relationship management.
That breadth may mean more choices to configure if you only want to publish a newsletter; it may be useful if you need several ways to engage and earn from fans. Before switching, map your current publishing and community needs to the features each platform lists, then account for the 10% earnings fee and any additional payment charges.
Questions people ask
What percentage of Substack subscriptions are paid?
The published information does not publish the share of Substack subscribers who pay, so we can’t give a platform-wide percentage. Substack’s listed fee is different: it takes 10% of subscription revenue from paid subscriptions, with Stripe processing and recurring billing fees potentially added.
What are some companies similar to Substack?
Patreon is one alternative for creators who want to offer memberships and exclusive work. Its listed features also include online shops, community tools, fan analytics, and relationship management. It is not described here as a direct newsletter substitute, so compare the features you rely on before switching.
Is Patreon.com a legit website?
The published product information describes Patreon as a platform for memberships, creator sales, and fan communities, but it does not independently verify the site’s legitimacy or security. We can confirm its listed pricing model is 10% of income earned, plus possible payment and other applicable fees.
Is Patreon hard to cancel?
The published information does not explain how to cancel a Patreon membership or how cancellation affects access, so we can’t assess how difficult it is. Before joining, check Patreon’s current cancellation instructions and the specific creator’s membership terms; those details are not included in the pricing information here.