We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Sellfy if you want a lower-cost creator store: annual billing starts at $22/month, with a 14-day trial and plan sales caps. Choose SamCart if checkout optimization matters more: annual billing starts at $59.25/month, and Pro adds upsells, order bumps and A/B testing. SamCart lists SamPay processing at 2.9% + 30¢; Sellfy lists 0% transaction fees, but gateway charges still apply and a 2% overage may apply above annual limits. Neither has a free plan.
01Side by side
| SamCart | Sellfy | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | From $79 monthly; $59.25 annual equivalent | From $29 monthly; $22 annual |
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan; 14-day trial |
| Best for | Product businesses focused on sales optimization | Creators selling downloads and merchandise |
| Core strength | Pro adds upsells, order bumps and A/B testing | Storefronts, downloads, subscriptions and print-on-demand |
| Learning curve | Not published | No-code store builder |
| Integrations/data | One marketplace on Core and Pro | PayPal, Stripe, Apple Pay, Google Pay, cards |
| Team/seat costs | 1 Core seat; 10 Pro; DFY unlimited | Seat limits not published |
| Support | Priority support on custom-priced Done For You | Priority support on Premium |
SamCart Choose SamCart if
- Choose SamCart if checkout optimization is a priority.
- Choose SamCart if you need order bumps and one-click upsells.
- Choose SamCart if you need more than one team seat.
Sellfy Choose Sellfy if
- Choose Sellfy if you want a lower starting price.
- Choose Sellfy if you need a no-code creator storefront.
- Choose Sellfy if print-on-demand merchandise is part of your catalog.
02Pricing compared
Sellfy starts lower: annual billing is listed at $22/month for Starter, $59 for Business and $119 for Premium. Monthly billing is $29, $79 and $159. Starter caps annual sales at $10,000; the higher plans cap them at $50,000 and $200,000. A 2% overage fee may apply above a plan limit until you upgrade. A 14-day trial is available, but there is no free plan.
SamCart’s Core plan is $79/month, or $59.25/month with the advertised annual discount. Pro is $199 monthly or $149.25 annualized. Core includes one team seat; Pro includes 10 and adds A/B testing, upsells and order bumps. SamPay processing is listed at 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction on both plans. Neither platform is simply the sticker price: Sellfy also passes through Stripe or PayPal fees, while SamCart lists additional tax-collection fees.
03Features and depth
Sellfy covers the basics of a creator storefront: digital downloads, subscriptions, physical goods and print-on-demand merchandise. Its plans include unlimited products, while file-size limits range from 10 GB on Starter to 20 GB on Premium. Marketing features include email campaigns, affiliate marketing, SEO and product upselling; Business also lists cart-abandonment tools. Sellfy says it has 11 print-on-demand fulfillment centers.
SamCart puts more emphasis on checkout optimization. It supports digital and physical products, courses, memberships, events and services, with course hosting and subscription recovery. Pro includes A/B testing, one-click upsells and order bumps; Core does not list those tools. The AI Assistant can generate business content, and Pages AI can build a sales page from a description, though Core has limited AI usage and Pro has unlimited AI usage. If your main need is a simple creator store, Sellfy has the broader low-cost entry point. If checkout add-ons and testing matter, SamCart Pro is better equipped, at a much higher price.
04Ease of use and learning curve
Sellfy is positioned as a no-code store builder, with free templates and a drag-and-drop editor. That makes its setup proposition straightforward, though its plan sales caps and email-credit limits still require attention as you grow. Starter includes 2,000 monthly email credits; Business includes 10,000 and Premium 50,000.
SamCart combines sales pages, checkout, billing and reporting, so there are more conversion features to configure. Its AI page builder may help create a starting point, but the available information does not establish how much setup or learning each tool takes. The reviews rate Sellfy higher for ease of use (8 versus 7 for SamCart), but neither review provides testing details. Choose based on the tools you need, not a promise of effortless setup.
Questions people ask
What is the downside of using Shopify?
The published product information does not cover Shopify’s pricing, limits or features, so we can’t substantiate a Shopify downside here. For this comparison, the documented trade-off is between Sellfy’s annual sales caps and SamCart’s higher entry price and listed SamPay processing fee.
Is SamCart good?
SamCart may suit sellers who need sales-page and checkout tools, including upsells, order bumps and A/B testing on Pro. Its Core plan starts at $79 monthly, and Pro at $199 monthly; annual billing is listed at lower monthly equivalents. Our review scores it 7 out of 10.
Who is the founder of SamCart?
The published SamCart information does not identify its founder, so we can’t verify or name one from these sources. It describes SamCart as an ecommerce platform for selling products, with sales pages, checkout, subscription billing, reporting and course hosting.
Who are Shopify's main competitors?
The published information does not identify Shopify’s main competitors or compare Shopify with either platform. SamCart and Sellfy are the two products in this comparison: Sellfy focuses on creator storefronts, while SamCart emphasizes checkout and sales optimization tools.