We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
These are not direct substitutes. Choose ADP Workforce Now for payroll and broader HR needs across business sizes; its homepage lists payroll and HR, with time, talent, benefits and workforce-management options by size. Pricing is not published, so budget fit is hard to judge. Choose TidyCal for service-provider scheduling, paid bookings and recurring sessions: it has a free plan and paid options from $29 once or $8.25 monthly billed annually. TidyCal is the clearer low-cost choice; ADP is for a different job.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | TidyCal | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | Not published | $0 free; Pro $12 monthly or $99 yearly |
| Free plan | Not listed | Yes; unlimited bookings, one calendar connection |
| Best for | Businesses needing payroll and broad HR solutions | Service providers scheduling and charging for appointments |
| Core strength | Payroll, HR and workforce solutions | Booking pages, payments and recurring sessions |
| Ease of use (review score) | 5 | 6 |
| Integrations and data | Specific integrations not listed on homepage | Google, Microsoft and Apple calendar syncing |
| Team and seat costs | Price and seat limits unpublished; targets 50–999+ employees | $79 Agency Lifetime; seat limits not published |
| Support (review score) | 5 | 4 |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if payroll and broad HR are your priority.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need HR options across business sizes.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if workforce management is part of your needs.
TidyCal Choose TidyCal if
- Choose TidyCal if you need a free plan for basic scheduling.
- Choose TidyCal if you sell appointments, packages or recurring sessions.
- Choose TidyCal if you want published prices and calendar syncing.
02Pricing compared
ADP Workforce Now does not publish pricing on the homepage, and the published pricing information lists no monthly or annual rates. Select, Plus and Premium are named plans for midsize to enterprise organizations, generally described as serving 50 to 999+ employees, but plan limits and prices are not published. Recruiting, performance, compensation and learning add-ons require custom quotes. That makes ADP hard to budget against before speaking with sales.
TidyCal is more transparent: its Free plan costs $0 and includes unlimited bookings and booking types, one calendar connection and a 1% fee on paid bookings. Lifetime plans cost $29 for Individual or $79 for Agency, also with a 1% fee. Pro costs $12 monthly or $99 yearly ($8.25 per month) and has no platform fee. For straightforward booking, TidyCal is the clearer low-cost option; these products do different jobs.
03Features and depth
ADP Workforce Now is the better fit when the job is payroll and broader HR, not appointment booking. ADP’s homepage lists payroll and HR solutions for small, midsized and large businesses. Its listed options vary by size: time and attendance for small and midsized businesses; talent for midsized businesses; benefits administration for midsized and large businesses; and workforce management for large businesses. The published information does not detail which features each Workforce Now plan includes.
TidyCal is built around scheduling for service providers. It offers a shareable booking page, availability settings, calendar syncing with Google, Microsoft and Apple, and automated email and SMS reminders. Clients can pay through Stripe or PayPal. TidyCal also supports recurring bookings and prepaid session packages, such as 5-packs and 10-packs. The Free plan has one calendar connection; Pro offers unlimited connections and SMS reminders. Those tools may help a coach or consultant take bookings, but they do not replace ADP’s payroll and HR scope.
04Ease of use and learning curve
The published information does not give enough detail to compare setup steps or the learning curve directly. TidyCal’s core workflow is easier to pin down: create a booking page, set availability, connect a calendar and choose whether to accept payments. Its free plan has basic integrations and one calendar connection; Pro removes those limits on calendar connections and SMS reminders.
ADP’s homepage describes a wider set of payroll and HR solutions, but does not explain Workforce Now setup or plan-by-plan access. Ask ADP what implementation and support involve before comparing effort or cost. A review summary flags limited polish and reported reliability issues for TidyCal, so its low price does not settle whether it suits your workflow.
Questions people ask
Can TidyCal replace ADP Workforce Now?
No, not based on the published product information. ADP lists payroll and HR solutions, with related workforce, time, talent and benefits options by business size. TidyCal focuses on booking pages, calendars, reminders and paid or recurring sessions. Choose based on the job you need done.
How much does ADP Workforce Now cost?
ADP Workforce Now pricing is not published on the vendor's site. Select, Plus and Premium are named, but their prices and seat limits are not listed. Recruiting, performance, compensation and learning add-ons are also custom-quote items, so ask ADP for a quote.
What is the cheapest TidyCal plan?
TidyCal has a free plan with unlimited bookings and booking types, one calendar connection and a 1% fee on paid bookings. Its paid options include a $29 Individual Lifetime plan and Pro at $12 monthly or $99 yearly, with no platform fee on Pro.
Does TidyCal charge a fee on paid bookings?
Yes, the Free, Individual Lifetime and Agency Lifetime plans charge a 1% platform fee on paid bookings. Pro has no platform fee. TidyCal also lists payment acceptance through Stripe or PayPal, so check the relevant payment provider’s own terms separately.